My wife didn't want a "girly" board either. She bought a Liquid Force Trip. It got solid reviews and seemed a good fit for her (more beginner) but that could grow with it also. But mostly she really liked the graphics - very colorful.
I haven't ridden it so can't comment on the ride.
She's also pretty small - 5'0" and 120. She's got the 134. It also works for kids/smaller teens who we have on the boat.