JMW - I checked the rudder and its still good! They replaced the seal itself and not the boot. You raise a good point about a possible tear on the boot. The water is coming in very slow and at the base (closest to transom) of the boot. The dealer did talk about being very careful when replacing the seal, so that they did not damage the new one. I'll get a mirror and look at the bottom of the boot first thing in the morning. It's definitely not going to sink, its just aggravating to pay for service and not receive it.
Traxx - Your post worked! Actually made me laugh! I love this forum. I've learned a ton of things from it and everyone helps out!!!!
Thanks for the info guys. I'll post back tomorrow with my findings.