Sounds like the starter drive (sometimes improperly referred to as "bendix") is not sliding on the shaft to engage the flywheel. I would remove the starter and do a bench test to see if that is the case. You certainly want to remove the starter and inspect before doing any damage if there is an alignment issue.
Two 14" 5 lug S5 wheels with ST205/75R14 Kenda Loadstar radials $349
Two 14" 5 lug S5 wheels with ST215/75R14 Kenda Loadstar radials $389
Two 15" 5 lug S5 wheels with ST205/75R15 Kenda Loadstar radials $409
Mounted, balanced and delivered.
PM or email me for tire, wheel or package pricing.
CARBURETOR REBUILDING - $199
Parts, labor and return shipping included
2 LED 6" BRAKE LIGHTS DELIVERED $32