I would be tempted to try one of the headlight polishing kits in a small spot to see if that would work.
CUSTOM WHEEL & TIRE PACKAGES
$125 LED LIGHT PACKAGE - FREE SHIPPING
REBUILDING HOLLEY MARINE CARBS - $249 DELIVERED
REBUILT COMPLETE MARINE HOLLEY 4160 CARBS
FOR 302, 351 & 454 STARTING AT $425
Email - firstname.lastname@example.org