The skateboard stuff is harsh and will promptly remove leg hair like a epilady. Ask me how I know. I got this stuff and it's the same texture and feel as the OE grip tape (i.e. not harsh on bare skin):
You'd obviously have to cut it out. I didn't cut out the MasterCraft logo and just matched the outside shape of mine and it worked well. Unless you find someone with old stock I don't think you can get the OE cut stuff. If you want a fancier solution look at HydroTurf or SeaDek.